Views

Saturday, 19 July 2014

New Councillor needed for Shalfleet - Do you want an election or let the Parish Council choose the new Councillor for you? If you do nothing, the Parish will choose for you. -- Update 3

The last two vacancies have now been advertised by SPC. The advertised date is 31st July 2014 and signatures requesting an election rather than co-option must be received by 20th August HOWEVER after discussion with the IWC sufficient signatures (more than ten) will be with the IWC by early next week to ensure that both polls take place at the same time to reduce costs and closure of the schools. I have been told that October 9th is a likely date for the election however it has to be cleared with the polling stations. Please block off October 9th in your diaries now -- I will let you know immediately we have confirmation or change. So there are three vacancies and almost anyone on the Shalfleet Electoral Register who has been resident for a year or more is entitled to stand. There is a lot going on in our parish now, with development proposals and the Localism Act (e.g. Bembridge's recent referendum) so perhaps more now than at any time for years, this parish election is of important to all residents. Whether you're standing, supporting or voting, it would be great to make this a good turnout.

Councillor Vacancy Advertisement 31-7-14 by david5174

Update 2 -- Rumours had been circulating that there had been other resignations on the Parish Council and that the Clerk had resigned.  Nothing had been posted on the Parish website or on the notice boards, so a resident kindly offered to make a Freedom of Information request.  The formal replies are in the file below, but:

Cllr Jacobs resigned and her vacancy was the one advertised on 17th July, which has been notified for election rather than co-option, under the Rule of Ten.  i.e. More than ten signatures (21, actually) were collected requesting the vacancy to be elected not co-opted.  At around the same time the Clerk, Mrs Jennins, resigned and tomorrow, Thursday 31st July 2014 is her last day.

Then another two Councillors decided to resign; Cllrs Burt and Whitney.  No reason for any of the resignations has been stated.  The two vacancies have not been advertised because the Clerk is waiting for instructions on procedure.  I phoned the IWC yesterday and found that the Electoral Services Manage is on leave until tomorrow, the Clerk's last day.  The following is the actual print-out from the Freedom of Information system.


SPC FOI Requests Re Resignations by david5174


Update 1 -- A list of twenty-one signatories was handed to the Electoral Services Manager on Tuesday 22nd July.  These have been accepted and the 'Rule of 10' is now in progress - i.e. the vacancy will be filled following an election.  The matter is now in the hands of the Isle of Wight Council and will proceed according to statutory procedures.  I believe it'll be a public announcement, in the County Press, on the IWC website and, I imagine, on the local Shalfleet notice boards.  I will keep an eye-out and update you as soon as I hear anything. If you wish to chase or find out more (you have a perfect right) then I suggest you contact Mr Clive Joynes, Electoral Services Manager, at County Hall on 823380.  Mr Joynes and his team are very approachable and will no doubt assist.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

A vacancy for a Councillor has arisen for Shalfleet Parish Council, dated 17th July 2014. The official webpage is here:- http://www.shalfleetiow.org.uk/councillor-vacancy/ I have reproduced the document below.  It is hard to read but on my reproduction below, you can use the + and - buttons to zoom.

The Parish Council have chosen not to tell us why the vacancy has arisen.  Usually it is because an existing Councillor has resigned or not attended for a long period.  The Parish Council has chosen not to tell us which Councillor is standing-down.  If we do nothing, then electors can put themselves forward to the Council to be considered for 'co-option'. That choice is made by the existing Council so you will have no say whatsoever.

If ten people write to the address below and ask for an election then almost any elector in the Parish can stand for the Parish Council.  It costs nothing to do this. The benefit is that it will be a proper democratic choice, not an appointee of the Parish Council.

If you would like to do this, you need to do it to arrive before 6th August 2014.  If that's what you are going to do then do so without delay.

6 comments:

  1. There is no cost to a qualified elector to stand to be a member for the Parish Council.

    However, if an election is called, the cost to the Parish Council is likely to be over £1000, We who live in the Parish fund the Parish Council and will pay. Is this the best use of our Council Tax?

    ReplyDelete
  2. That's not quite right, Steve. We in the Parish don't pay directly to the Parish Council. We pay the Isle of Wight Council (IWC) which also receives central government support. The IWC then transfers a sum called a 'precept' to the Parish Council.

    According to the IWC Electoral Services Manager, It is best practice for Parish and Town Councils to make provision for their Democratic obligations so this should already be budgeted for. The system is laid down by Act of Parliament.

    The Parish Council is a democratically-elected body and that by its very nature means an election.

    I'm not really sure what your point is about the best use of our Council Tax. What do you suggest? Not holding elections, and ceasing to have democratic Parish Councils?

    Suppose there was a vacancy for an IWC Ward, would we not have an election for a new Councillor, or would we allow the governing administration to select the new Councillor, presumably one who supports the administration? That doesn't feel right and is certainly not democratic.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I find my self agreeing with what David says......we have to have a fair system and everybody in the parish should be aware that there are positions coming up if anyone wants to apply and that they have aright to vote.....I think that's called democracy!! This applies to all parish councils all over the UK. Other wise it al becomes a bit of a "them and us" situation between parishioners and the parish council. From my experience so far it all appears very one sided!

    ReplyDelete
  4. The above comment by 'Anonymous' was posted by Rowena Nihell who wasn't able to log-in with a user-name and asked me to add her real name.

    ReplyDelete
  5. David,

    Your comments show a lack of understanding of how Parish Councils work.
    Parish Councils get no financial support from central government or the Isle of Wight Council. The Parish Council sets its budget each year; this includes a sum to allow for an election. The Parish Council sets the precept which the Isle of Wight Council collects on its behalf.

    Elections are indeed about democracy which relies on willingness of residents to put themselves forward to be elected. Many parish councils find it very difficult to persuade people to come forward.

    It appears that we now need 4 residents to put their names forward to trigger an election as there are 3 vacancies.
    There was an election in May 2013. Not a single resident other than the existing councillors put their name forward so no election was called.This is still democracy. You do not need an election unless a place is contested.

    Let's hope that there are at least 4 people ready willing and able to stand for election now. There is no 'them and us', The parish council is made up of the residents who put their names forward.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Steve, it is more complicated than that. Electoral Services say that because the Councillors resigned at different times it may not be legal to lump the second two (Burt and Whitney) with the first (Jacobs). Mrs Jennings says (in the information I posted) that she needs clarification about the procedure. We wait to be advised by IWC.

    ReplyDelete